You see, graduate school has this special power to make you loathe the things you thought you loved. Sometimes my relationship with poetry makes me feel guilty and cynical and conflicted, but then I think: what is poetry really about anyway if not passionate ambivalence?
While I don’t read much poetry in general, I make a special point of not reading poetry in The New Yorker. It tends to run two types of poems: b-sides from famous poets who are well past their prime, or paragraphs that end with lines like “Translated from the Polish.” (It’s the article that kills me—the Polish.) That said, I’m a big fan of the magazine's profiles, so I had no compunction about reading a recent profile Rebecca Mead wrote about identical twins and rising poets Michael and Matthew Dickman.
I’ll admit I was also drawn in by the photograph that accompanied the article, in which these twins somehow manage to look thoroughly Other and totally hot at the same time. I can’t figure out how they pull this off given that one Dickman looks like any given member of Duran Duran circa “Hungry Like the Wolf” and the other reminds me a little of Clay Aiken. I can't find the photo from the article, but this should give you an idea of what I'm talking about:


The article (“Couplet”) is actually really interesting even though I think it’s mostly a gimmicky exploitation of the inherent weirdness surrounding identical twins. This writer is all about twin mind-meld and painting a picture of these brothers as the town freaks, which seems like a bit of a stretch given that they live in Portland, for heaven’s sake.
Despite the tabloid sideshow-vibe of the article, it wasn’t until, like, page seven that I learned that the twins played the “pre-cogs” in Minority Report, those strange hairless albino creatures that softly thrash and moan in Tom Cruise’s Creepy Swimming Pool of the Future. I suppose that little piece of trivia really does make a strong town-freak argument, but still: Portland.
In retrospect, what I like least about Mead’s article is the quotes that she chose to represent the Dickmans’ poetry. She started off strong with this Michael Dickman quote, a sort of romanticising of abuse that reminded me a lot of Theodore Roethke:
They used to be good at being alive,
pointing their index fingers at
the trees, passing
invisible sentences
proclamations
knighting the birds
one by one
All down my street the new fathers
beat the kingness
out
of the
kings
(“Kings”)
But from there her choices became problematic. The first Matthew Dickman excerpt makes him sound like a high school kid who just read Ginsberg for the first time:
Dear Lents, dear 82nd avenue, dear 92nd
and Foster,
I am your strange son.
(“Lents District”)
Her descriptions of their poetry are downhill from there—she casts Matthew as a practitioner of delirious sentimentality in the tradition of Ginsberg and Whitman, when he in fact puts me more in mind of Frank O’Hara’s upbeat melancholia. And she makes Michael’s poetry sound really desperate and bleak when in fact it has this sort of strange religious quality. It was a misguided exercise in compare-and-contrast, and now that I’ve been reading their poems, I’d say she has the inversion exactly wrong. There is something really sad and dark at the heart of Matthew’s exuberance (see “Grief,” which blew me away), whereas the whole point of Michael’s poems seems to be transcending his own gloomy trappings. In fact, Michael can be really funny:
I think the light
appearing, then
disappearing
across the trunk of the live oak
is the boss of everything
Not You
(“Good Friday”)
In any case, by the end of the article, I was in L-U-V with Matthew Dickman, eighties hairstyle notwithstanding. Because how can you not love someone who tells an anecdote wherein he makes out with Allen Ginsberg out of pity, or who describes his childhood thusly:
“We were fiercely picked on. We were weird; we were twins; we had these government-issue glasses; and our last name had the words ‘dick’ and ‘man’ in it. So we came home crying a lot of the time.”
And while I think the Rebecca Mead got a lot of things wrong, what really shines through in every sentence she wrote is how the Brothers Dickman are totally in love with each other in the best possible way. Won over, I went out and bought both of their books—the rather epic sounding All-American Poem (by Matthew) and The End of the West (by Michael)--the first books of poetry I bought since grad school...and also the first time I've felt positive about poets-as-people in a very long time.
Check them out. These guys are the real deal.






